Skip to content
SEOCheckGet $100 free

Link quality

A good link, defined in plain terms

People ask what makes a backlink high quality and get a list of vague adjectives. Here is a checklist you can run in five minutes.

SEOCheck research team ·

Stone bridge connecting two land masses with smaller footbridges in the distance

Quality is mostly relevance

A link earns its weight by who gives it and why. A page on a related topic, written for readers, pointing to you because you add something. That is the model case.

Strength of the linking site matters, but less than people think. Small is not a flaw. A tiny niche blog can beat a huge generic site for your query. Everything else is a variation on that theme.

Any backlink checker can find candidates, but only you can judge them. Judge them yourself. Use the tool to build the list, then read each linking page yourself. A backlink checker is a finder, not a judge.

Think about how a human editor would choose. Moz and Majestic built their own trust metrics for this reason, and Ahrefs and Semrush each sell one too. All of them approximate a judgment you can partly make by reading the page. Skim it. Is it something a person would bookmark?

Reading the page pays twice. A useful side effect is that you notice what the linker cares about. That tells you what to pitch next time, and which of your pages deserve the traffic. Compare it with how scores disagree before leaning on any one number. When you suspect a drop in value, the diagnosis order tells you what to check first.

Five-minute link test

  • Does the linking page have real text and real readers?
  • Is its topic close to yours?
  • Is the link inside the body, not a footer or sidebar list?
  • Does the anchor read naturally in the sentence?
  • Does the page link out to dozens of unrelated sites?
  • Would you accept this link with search engines turned off?

Red flags

Casinos and essay mills

If a site links to those, a link there tells Google little you want to hear.

Identical anchors everywhere

A profile of mostly exact-match text looks engineered. Check yours with anchors.

Pages with no visits

A guest post on a dead blog still counts as a link on paper, little more.

Swaps on request

A reciprocal link now and then is normal. Systematic exchanges are a pattern.

Internal links versus backlinks

Both help. They do different jobs.
Internal linkBacklink
Who controls itYouSomeone else
Main jobShow Google and readers your structureSignal that others find you worth citing
Speed of effectQuick once crawledSlow, depends on the linker
Risk of overdoingLow, but diluted focusHigher: spam patterns
Can it replace the otherNoNo
Garden with mixed flowers and uniform plant rows tended by a gardener

Smaller questions, short answers

Are footer links good? Mostly neutral. Site-wide links from one domain count as one linking domain in our data anyway, so a thousand footer links give you a count of one.

Should the homepage link use the brand name or the niche? Both. A mix looks like what real writers do. Over-using a keyword phrase is the part that stands out.

Do internal links hurt if you add too many? Not on their own, but they dilute importance. Aim at pages that matter. Does Google ignore some? Yes, and often because the link is buried or the target is a duplicate.

Link building rarely ends completely. Over time, though, the effort can shift from chasing links to maintaining them, because a site that earns links by existing needs less outreach. That is the point where the work starts to feel lighter.

Check your own profile as well. Since the Penguin update became real-time in September 2016, bad links tend to be discounted rather than punished, but a pattern of paid placements can still hurt trust. Run an anchors call on your domain every quarter and keep the file. The competitor teardown shows how to compare your profile against rivals.

Internal links: audit them like backlinks

Internal links are the one kind of link you fully control, so they deserve the same care as the external ones. A quick audit usually finds two or three pages that do most of the work and several that nothing points to.

Start from the site itself. Export the list of your pages and the links between them, then sort the result by how many internal links each page receives.

Find the pages no internal link reaches

Any page with zero internal links is hard for both readers and crawlers to find. Say you run a site of forty guides and six of them receive no links from the rest of the site. Those six are the first candidates for a link from a related guide.

Do not link to every page from the homepage. A homepage with hundreds of links dilutes the signal, and readers scan it for the three things they came for.

Check the anchor text inside the site

Internal anchors should describe the target in plain words. A link that says click here tells a reader nothing and tells a crawler less. Use the page topic as the anchor, and vary the wording so that each link reads like part of a sentence.

Decide which pages should receive links

Point the most links at the pages you want to rank and the pages that answer the most questions. Those pages should also be the ones with the most useful content. A link to a thin page does not make it strong.

Too many internal links on one page does not usually hurt on its own. The real cost is focus: when every page links everywhere, none of them stands out.

Link depth and crawl paths

A page buried five clicks from the homepage is harder to find than one linked from a main section. Count the clicks from the homepage to each important page. If a page you care about sits deep, add a link from a higher level page that already gets visits.

Keep the path short and logical. A reader who follows the links should land on the next useful page, not on a list of tags.

Compass on a table with a person examining a plant in the background

Finding quality backlink sites

The best candidates often sit where your rivals already earned links. Look there first. Their linkers have shown that they write about the topic. That is a far better start than a list of directories sold as a bundle.

Work through the candidates one at a time. Read the page, check the topic and decide whether you would want your name beside it.

Start from shared linkers

Run intersect on two or three strong competitors. The domains that link to all of them are warm leads, because the topic clearly interests them. Sort those by relevance first and by score second.

Are backlinks more important than content?

That question has no clean answer. Links carry the signal that other sites vouch for you. Content gives those sites a reason to link at all. A weak page rarely earns good links, and a strong page with no links is hard to find.

For a small site, improving one good page usually beats building links to a weak one. Then the links you earn point at something worth reading.

Outreach that earns a link

Write to a site only when you have something it would want to cite. A data point helps, and so does a clear method or a fix for a problem the site already discusses. Short, specific messages get read more often than long pitches. Keep the first message under a hundred words.

Where a directory listing fits

A directory can help people find you, but a long list of automatically submitted listings adds little. Choose a few that are edited, relevant to your niche and actually used by people in the field. One good listing is worth more than fifty that nobody reads.

How many links is enough?

There is no fixed count that works for every site. A focused site with a few strong, relevant links can outperform a broad one with hundreds of weak ones. Judge the set as a whole: the spread of topics, the share of editorial links and the pages they reach.

If the audit shows one linker supplying most of your links, that is a risk worth noting even when the link itself is good.

Even shorter

How do I audit anchors?

Run anchors or anchor_cloud on your domain. Two credits each. If one phrase dominates, diversify.

Where do I find good targets?

Run intersect on two or three strong competitors. Shared linkers are warm leads.

Do directories help?

A few relevant, edited ones can. Mass submission rarely does.

Audit a link profile in five steps

Each step produces a small file or a note. Keep them together, so the next quarter starts from this one.

01

Pull your anchors

Run anchors on your domain. Two credits. Save the result with the date, so you can compare it later.

02

Open the top linking pages

Start with the ten domains that send the most links. Read each page and note whether the link sits in the body text.

03

Sort by relevance

Mark each linker as on topic, loosely related or off topic. Off-topic links are not always harmful, but they need a reason to exist.

04

Note the weak sources

Flag pages with no visits, obvious link lists and identical anchors. Do not disavow in a panic; write the list first and decide with it in front of you.

05

Set the quarterly date

Put the next audit in the calendar now. A profile you check once a year cannot tell you what changed.